Curses Aren’t to Blame for Indians’ Postseason Woes

The abrupt end to a season – especially one with expectations as high as the Indians had – is always met with a certain amount of navel contemplation.

What did the players do wrong? What did we as fans do wrong? What can we do better? Who stays? Who goes?

Unfortunately, it’s also met with a certain amount of irrationality (standard disclaimer: “Fan” is short for “fanatic”), and this year promises to be no better.

There’s a lot of talk of curses – something that happens any time a team exhibits a strange sustained skid. And it’s easy to look at the Indians and believe there’s some kind of otherworldly force aligned against them. I mean, the team won 102 games this year and was all but penciled in for the World Series. But everything went wrong for the team in their three straight losses to the Yankees, from batting to pitching to fielding.

And it’s easy to think the team’s snakebit. This is the third time in the Tribe’s last four postseason appearances that the season ended with three straight losses after a two-game advantage in a playoff series. In the entire history of the World Series, there have been four winner-take-all Game 7s that have gone into extra innings. The Indians have lost two – 19 years apart, in 1997 and again last year.

For the 40 years of futility between the Indians’ 1954 sweep in the World Series and their Central Division crown in 1995, columnist Terry Pluto coined the idea of the curse of Rocky Colavito, who was traded away for Harvey Kuenn in a pathological fit by Frank Lane – and later reacquired at the cost of Tommie Agee, Tommy John, and John Romano.

But as of late, there’s a theory that the Indians have been vexed by the bad karma engendered by their mascot, Chief Wahoo.

The popular origin story of Chief Wahoo is that Bill Veeck, when he became owner of the team in 1946, commissioned a caricature of an Indian to serve as the team’s mascot, and he’s been part of the team’s logo and apparel since. However, like the origin of the team’s name, it carries more myth than fact. There has been an Indian mascot on uniforms dating back to the 1920s, and drawings that look a lot like Wahoo appeared in the Plain Dealer 15 years before the first official iteration of Chief Wahoo.

Now, the purpose of this piece is not to litigate Chief Wahoo (but if you’re clamoring for my opinion, I’d be happy to see it go. It appalls me that a team that’s been as racially progressive as the Indians – home to the first African-American manager in Major League Baseball and the first African-American player in the American League – has as its mascot what could charitably be described as a caricature). It’s to talk about curses.

It’s easy to use curses as an excuse. Boston’s Curse of the Bambino conveniently ignores the Red Sox’s own history of racism. The Cubs’ curse of the Billy Goat ignores decades of neglect from owners. And Chief Wahoo didn’t make the Indians hit .150 in the last three games of the American League Division Series, or commit seven errors in the last two games.

Related Posts

Repeat of Last Winter’s Spending Not Necessary For Tribe to Be 2018 Title Contenders

Last year, the Cleveland Indians made one of the biggest free agent signings of the winter. The guaranteed $60 million for three years doled out to slugger…

Atchison Joins Cleveland Coaching Staff as Bullpen Coach

The Cleveland Indians formally announced on Thursday afternoon that former Tribe reliever Scott Atchison had been hired as the bullpen coach on manager Terry Francona‘s staff for…

Indians Bring Back Willis for Another Stint as Pitching Coach

One of the big questions looming over the Cleveland front office this offseason was answered on Thursday morning as the Indians announced that Carl Willis has been…

Cleveland Connections in the 2017 World Series

This is the type of story that should not have been written, as had all gone according to plan, the Cleveland Indians would be back-to-back winners of…

Indians With Another Coaching Vacancy as Quatraro Returns to Rays

When a team finds sustained success on the field, they oftentimes run the risk of losing some of the coaches that helped get them there as opportunity…

Indians Add Pitching Coach to Offseason Needs as Callaway Joins Mets

Nearly four years ago, I met Mickey Callaway for the first time. He had just completed his first season with the Indians as the pitching coach on…

This Post Has 2 Comments

  1. Hey- if believing it is a curse will convince enough people to do the right thing and support getting rid of the Chief Wahoo, then I’m all for the belief.

    On a side note- I generally read your site via an RSS feed, So I’m rarely confronted by your own site’s use of the caricature. Why does your site insist on using it? Have you had internal discussion as to why it occupies space on your page?

  2. It’s the best logo in baseball; not offensive and very motivational….’Keep Whahoo’ should be the slogan of all Indian fans…..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.