As Did The Tribe Win Last Night helps fans count down the days until the Indians retake the field in an official Major League game, we look back at some of the players who wore the Cleveland jersey with pride.
Countdown to Opening Day – 63 days
According to the fantastic resource that is Baseball-Reference.com, 129 players have worn the number 63 in a Major League game during their careers. The Cleveland Indians have had five players from that list use the digits, with three of them providing some of the best career statistics of a number 63 to date.
Eric Bell was the first Cleveland Indians player to wear 63 when he took the mound for the Tribe as a reliever in 1991 and 1992, working in 17 games, making just one start, and posting a 4-2 record with a 3.78 ERA in those two years. Andrew Lorraine brought the number back to begin the next decade during his ten-game stay as a reliever for the club in 2000. Once Victor Martinez debuted the number in his first dozen Major League games in 2002, he set the trend for excellence for the number in Indians history.
Martinez, the Venezuelan-born catching prospect, was a September call-up that season after being signed as an amateur free agent by the team in 1996. He would sport the number just that season, later switching to 20 for the 2003 season before settling into the 41 that he has worn every year and every stop of his career since. He is the WAR leader of all 129 players to ever wear the number at some point in their professional action.
Another Venezuelan, this time a pitcher, would make the number memorable midway through the 2003 season.
Right-hander Rafael Betancourt was signed by the Boston Red Sox as an amateur free agent late in the 1993 season. He joined the Sox not as a pitcher, but as a light-hitting infielder, spending parts of three seasons in Rookie and A-ball playing at second, short, and third base.
The problem for Betancourt was that he couldn’t hit well and he couldn’t play without errors in the field, both fairly important parts of being a professional infielder. After three years on the farm, he hit a combined .195. In those years, he committed four errors in 27 games at third base, six errors in 36 games at second, and 22 errors in 79 games at short. So, in 1997, the club converted him to pitcher to capitalize on an otherwise strong arm.
He spent three seasons pitching for the Red Sox, climbing to Double-A, but went overseas to Yokohama of the Japan Central League in 2000. He returned in 2001 to the Red Sox, but became a free agent after the season.
The Indians found their diamond in the rough when they signed him as a free agent early in 2003. His results were far better than those while in the Boston organization. He earned 16 saves in 31 games for Double-A Akron, posting a 1.99 ERA and striking out 75 batters in 45 1/3 innings before being promoted to Triple-A Buffalo. After four games there, he was promoted to Cleveland, never to return to the minors for reason other than rehab assignments.
Betancourt became the bridge in the Indians bullpen, setting the stage for setup man David Riske and closer Danys Baez in 2003. He continued to excel as a late inning reliever for manager Eric Wedge to set up Riske and closer Bob Wickman, when he returned in July. During the 2005 season when coming in during the seventh inning, he struck out 22 of 89 batters while walking just one. The next season, he struggled some and was used a lot by Wedge in games in which the club was trailing, so he earned just seven holds that season.
“For three years [1998-2000], I pitched in pain,” said Betancourt in a story in the August 11, 2003 edition of The Plain Dealer. “All I was hoping for after the surgery was to get another chance. It took 16 months of rehabilitation to come back after the surgery. I didn’t know if I would come back healthy enough to ever pitch in the big leagues. For three years before the surgery, I was not able to throw a breaking ball because of the pain. I’d go into games not only having to think about the batter, but about the pain. My mind was going crazy.
“Now, I am able to worry only about the batter.”
The 2007 season thrust him onto the map. He appeared in a career-high tying 68 games and earned three saves while posting a 5-1 record and 1.47 ERA. He struck out 80 batters, a personal single-season best at the time, in 79 1/3 innings and limited the opposition with a 0.76 WHIP. More importantly, in addition to matching four years of holds in one season with 31, he allowed just 9% of inherited runners to score as just three of 33 touched home plate with him on the mound. His strong setup work allowed Joe Borowski to save 45 games and helped the Indians reach the American League Championship Series.
The numbers for “Raffy Right” bloated in 2008, as he went 3-4 with four saves and had a 5.07 ERA while continuing to team with “Raffy Left”, Rafael Perez, out of the bullpen. Prior to the trade deadline in 2009, a restructuring Indians team sent the 34-year-old reliever with a steadily climbing contract to the Colorado Rockies for minor leaguer Connor Graham. Betancourt left Cleveland as the club’s single-season leader for holds with 31 (broken by Vinnie Pestano in 2012) and all-time leader in the stat with 84 (broken by Joe Smith in 2013).
He has continued wearing 63 with the Rockies, where he has been since the trade while working for stretches as the team’s closer. He returned last season and struggled after Tommy John surgery.
The number 63 did not go unused by the Indians for long, as just over a week after the trade, the Indians acquired relief pitcher Justin Masterson and he claimed the number for his own.
Masterson came to Cleveland eight days after Betancourt departed in the trade that sent Martinez to Boston. He had worn 63 in his first two campaigns for the Red Sox and continued the trend with the Indians, even while struggling to adapt as a full-time starter who would go 1-7 with a 4.55 ERA in eleven games.
The big right-hander went 6-13 with a 4.70 ERA in 34 games in 2010, but turned it around in 2011, posting his first winning season since his rookie year with a 12-10 record and a much better 3.21 ERA in 34 games. In 2012, he was 11-15 with a 4.93 ERA, but led the league with 34 starts and was the team’s Opening Day starter.
Like Betancourt, Masterson made his mark on a team headed to the postseason. In 2013, he made the All-Star team for the first time in his career. He was the team’s Opening Day starter again and was 10-7 at the break with a 3.72 ERA and had 137 strikeouts in 135 1/3 innings. He threw a five-hit shutout in April, a four-hit shutout in May, and a six-hit shutout in June.
With the Indians trying to stay in contention in the playoff race in September, Masterson was bit by the injury bug. He strained his left oblique muscle during his September 2nd start and was gone by the second inning and was shelved for several starts. He returned for three relief appearances to close out the year as the Indians ran off ten straight to head to the AL Wild Card play-in game that they hosted against the Tampa Bay Rays.
Masterson was again the lead pitcher on the Indians staff to start the 2014 season, but was ineffective and later took a trip to the disabled list to shorten his time with the club. A pending free agent, he was dealt to the St. Louis Cardinals at the trade deadline, where he continued to struggle as a starter and was used in the final month of the season solely in relief. He returned to Boston for the 2015 season, but was released in August and later had surgery after struggling there.
The number 63 is not currently assigned to an active roster member of the Indians, but whomever wears it next has big shoes to fill.
Photo: Joy R. Absalon/USA TODAY Sports