The Glass is Half Something—Random Thoughts from September

“Never let your head hang down. Never give up and sit down and grieve. Find another way. And don’t pray when it rains if you don’t pray when the sun shines.”

-Richard M. Nixon


Personally, my playoff dreams for the Indians felt crushed in late April, but I—as everyone around baseball should—have to give the Indians some credit for hanging around in the race into the last week of the season. We are likely down to hours away from being officially eliminated, but at the very least, they kept us entertained all summer long. Thanks for a fun summer Tribe.


Sometimes I get this bad feeling in the pit of my stomach when I think about this team. I’m not talking about memories of the helmet-sized super nachos or the delicious but deadly deep-fried cookie dough that you can eat at Progressive Field, but about the fear that this is the kind of team that the Indians are going to try and sell the fans on for the next several seasons. I’m afraid of an annual patchwork team that is constructed of a few solid homegrown players and filled out with baseball’s spare parts along the way. The yearly “impact” free agent signings of guys like David Murphy, John Axford, Ryan Raburn, Mark Reynolds and Brett Myers are enough to make a caffeine-hopped teenager yawn. Worse yet, a team counting on players of that caliber are never going to be title contenders. I foresee a lot of teams that win between 79 and 88 games with an occasional Wild Card spot thrown in. I never foresee a parade heading down East Ninth Street with this philosophy, however.


Did you watch ESPN’s Sportscenter on Monday morning?

If you did, you probably heard anchor John Buccigross mention Did the Tribe Win Last Night? writer Todd Paquette’s tweet about Michael Brantley and how he will become the first player in Indians history with 200 hits, 40 doubles, 20 homeruns and 20 steals in a single season if he can reach the 200 hit plateau—a feat that he is within four hits of.

The point is—Brantley has had one hell of a season.

Here’s some more tweeted-out Dr. Smooth facts courtesy our now most-famous writer (@IndiansAccounts):

-Brantley’s .320+ average will be the highest by an Indian since Roberto Alomar hit .336 in 2001.

-Brantley has the most hits (196) in a single season by an Indian this century.

-Brantley has the third highest wRC+ (154) of all Indians in the past decade, trailing only Travis Hafner’s 2006 and 2005 seasons.


Amazingly enough, Brantley’s star wasn’t even the brightest shining on the Indians team this year, as Corey Kluber has outshined every player east of Seattle this season. Just like the team he plays for, every time it seemed that Kluber was likely going to fall just a little shy of his goal (in this case—the AL Cy Young Award), he did something to bring his name right back into the conversation.

The award has seemed to be the Mariners Felix Hernandez’s for the taking all season long, but Kluber has consistently battled and has put on a huge push over the past month. Kluber has won his last four outings while pitching one complete game and two starts of eight innings or more as well. Even more impressive are his last two starts where he set a new career high on September 16 in Houston with 14 strikeouts and then matched the feat five days later in Minnesota. Another one of those could launch Kluber to the top of the race and knock King Felix off of his throne in the season’s final weekend. If nothing else, it will give us all a reason to watch him this weekend.


With Brantley and Kluber in the fold for the next several years, another nebula could be turning into a star right before our very eyes as well.

Yan Gomes is really, really good and he’s getting better and better. Tribe fans should be excited to see what the future brings for Gomes because he’s under team control through the 2021 season assuming that his club options are picked up. Gomes already has impressive offensive numbers for his first two years in Cleveland (.287/31/109 in 219 games) and it’s worth mentioning just how low the bar is set when it comes to Indians catching greats.

There are basically three catchers that could arguably hold the title of greatest catcher in Indians history: Jim Hegan, Sandy Alomar, Jr. and Victor Martinez. All three were outstanding at what they did well, but all had glaring holes in their game as well. Aside from an abysmal April defensively, Gomes does not seem to have many large gaps at this time.

Hegan was the catcher on the 1948 Championship team during a career where he caught over 15,000 games in 14 years with the Tribe. The problem with Hegan was certainly not defense, but offense, as he batted only .230 during his long stay in Cleveland.

Alomar was the next long-term great, but Sandy’s career was hampered by injuries. Yes, he had multiple signature moments during the 1997 season and postseason, but the rest of his time in Cleveland was either spent on the DL or buried at the bottom of the Tribe’s hefty lineup. Over 11 seasons, Alomar’s offensive game probably isn’t as great as you remember it (.277/92/453) nor was his defense (a dWAR of over 1.0 just twice and below 0.0 once).

Finally there’s Martinez, who was the best hitter of them all, but the worst defender. Martinez batted .297 during his Cleveland tenure with 103 homeruns and 518 RBI. He was brutal behind the plate (zero seasons above 1.0 dWAR and three times below 0.0) and probably spent more time at first base and DH than most people realize.

It certainly is far too early, but if Gomes can continue to stay healthy and improve, he could move up the ladder very quickly into some elite company among Tribe catching greats.


Normally the Stock Up and Stock Down Awards are monthly achievements and focus on how I feel the player projects for the rest of the season. Since there are only four games left, however, this month’s edition will project those heading forward and how they compare heading into 2015 to how they looked back in March.

Stock Up Awards go to: Austin Adams, Cody Allen, Trevor Bauer, Brantley, Carlos Carrasco, Kyle Crockett, Lonnie Chisenhall, Gomes, Tyler Holt, T.J. House, Kluber, Francisco Lindor, Roberto Perez, Jose Ramirez and Zach Walters.


Stock Down “Awards” go to: Mike Aviles, Michael Bourn, Jason Giambi, Jason Kipnis, Zach McAllister, Murphy, Raburn, Nick Swisher and Josh Tomlin.

That’s 15 thumbs up and nine thumbs down…I guess that’s a good sign moving into next season.

SEASON MVP: Michael Brantley


Photo: Bob Levey/Getty Images

Related Posts

Swisher Gets His Happy Ending – But Not with Tribe

When the Indians signed Nick Swisher after a disastrous 2012 season, optimism was running high. His bubbly personality couldn’t help but rub off on his teammates. The…

How Long Can the Tribe Hold on to Sandy?

He came to Cleveland in a blockbuster trade, played the bulk of his career here as part of those great teams in the 1990s, and the entirety…

Johnny Baseball

With Johnny Manziel-mania having already swept through Cleveland, Berea and Browns Backer’s bars across the nation, the rookie quarterback who had never taken an NFL snap brought…

Kluber Wins Cy Young, Hopefully Won’t Follow Path of Sabathia and Lee

Indians’ fans slept well last night as they were given something to celebrate this season: Corey Kluber became the fourth Tribe pitcher to win the AL Cy…

Traded to the Playoffs: The Eventual Seasons for the Indians’ Three Biggest Trades of 2014

This season did not turn out the way the Indians had anticipated when they started 2014. Playoff dreams remained just that, dreams, and despite their overall winning…

Why is Cleveland Not a Tribe Town?

Today continues DTTWLN’s three week examination of the Indians’ 2014 season and where it fell short of the playoff expectations established last winter. The staff will examine…

This Post Has 2 Comments

  1. I appreciate this review of 2014 and share much of the opinions; but, I would disagree on the label for Mike Aviles. Aviles has been asked to play quite a few defensive positions under varying circumstance and acquitted himself very well. In addition, regardless of his offensive numbers, he has made some positive contributions offensively. I also feel that David Murphy has performed about as well as could be expected. His defensive has been adequate and he has been a “gritty” if not powerful hitter. I do whole heartedly agree with the comments about Jan Gomes. His offense has been a wonderful bonus, although he does have holes in his swing and too often swings and misses at low outside pitches after having just taken a pitch right down the middle. I find my self feeling much more calm about runners on base with Gomes behind the plate. And I base this not only on his success throwing out runners; but, the unknown times good runners do not challenge his arm for fear of being thrown out. And, this in no way disparages Perez’s contribution as a backup catcher. He has shown good defense and acceptable offense. The analysis of 2014 could be a glass half full if the front office makes substantive moves to improve our offense, particularly in the area of right handed power, and to supplement our improving pitching, exactly what they failed to do prior to this season, the prime reason we are not in the playoffs this year, unless a miracle happens, and a contributing factor to our low attendance.

  2. Your assessment of ownership’s view of fielding a team is en pointe. Sift through waivers and medium range free agents and see how it shakes out. Mix in a successful trade (Gomes from Toronto) and you’re looking at ‘competitive’.

    Tom Hamilton said on the air that Victor Martinez and similar free agents were unlikely to be coming to Cleveland- that’s encouraging.

    Mike Aviles has OBP of .296. Gritty or otherwise, that is not useful. 14 walks= terrible, on the same team with Carlos Santana. Bye, handsome Mike.

    Mystery man? Jason Kipnis. I believe he is being ‘pitched to,’ and that there is small mystery about how to get him out around the league. .242 w/ 6 homers? Hard to tell.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.